Why Esau Hates Jacob

Jacob has to flee from his brother Esau. The reason is that Esau sold the birthright to Jacob for a pot of porridge. This is the story of Jew haters. The feel that they are owed something for nothing. Unfortunately, this story repeats itself throughout history.

A Quick Dvar Torah – Parshat Toldot

The Difference Between Earning Something and Believing You Are Entitled to It

In this week’s parsha, we see Yaakov running away from his brother Esav, who wants to kill him. Why is Esav so angry? Because he believes Yaakov stole something that rightfully belonged to him—the bechorah, the birthright of the firstborn.

But wait a minute. Did Yaakov really steal the bechorah?

Remember what happened. Esav came in from the field, hungry and exhausted. Yaakov was preparing a pot of lentils, and Esav demanded something to eat. Yaakov offered him a deal: I’ll give you the food, but in exchange, you give me your birthright.

And Esav agreed!

The Torah tells us that Esav ate, drank, got up, and went on his way. And then it adds something very important: Vayivez Esav et habechorah—Esav despised the birthright.

In other words, even after he had eaten and was no longer hungry, he still considered the birthright worthless.

Esav was a man who lived for the moment. He was a hunter. He went out looking for his next meal rather than planning for the future. Yaakov, on the other hand, understood the importance of planning ahead.

The Midrash goes even further in describing Esav’s character. It portrays him as someone who didn’t just hunt animals; he also treated people as prey. He would rob others, taking what they had worked to earn.

And that’s an important distinction. A robber doesn’t ask himself how someone earned his money. He simply sees that the other person has something he wants, and he takes it.

Now, let’s return to the birthright.

Yaakov didn’t steal it. He bought it. He offered Esav a price, and Esav willingly accepted. We might question whether it was a wise transaction, but Esav agreed to it. Only later, when he realized what he had lost, did he become angry and blame Yaakov.

And this brings us to a much broader lesson.

Throughout history, the Jewish people have often been remarkably successful, despite facing tremendous obstacles. Jewish families have achieved success in education, business, science, medicine, and many other fields.

Why? In large part because of an emphasis on education, hard work, planning, and preparing for the future.

But success can create jealousy.

When someone sees another person succeeding, he has two choices. He can ask, “What did that person do right? What can I learn from him?” Or he can say, “Why does he have something that I don’t have? It’s not fair!”

And sometimes that jealousy turns into resentment.

Karl Marx famously promoted the principle, “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs.” The problem arises when people believe they are entitled to receive without accepting responsibility for producing.

We saw an early example of the difficulties of communal economic arrangements among the Plymouth colonists. Their initial system created problems with incentives and productivity, and they eventually moved toward individual household farming.

The lesson is that when people benefit from their own efforts, they often have a stronger incentive to work and produce.

And consider the State of Israel.

When Israel became independent in 1948, it was a poor country. It had very limited natural resources, faced enormous security challenges, and was absorbing hundreds of thousands of immigrants.

Look at Israel today.

It has become one of the world’s most technologically advanced economies. It has made extraordinary contributions to medicine, agriculture, science, and technology.

Was all of this simply handed to Israel?

Of course not.

It was built through generations of hard work, education, sacrifice, innovation, and determination.

Yet there are those who look at Israel’s success and assume that somehow it must have come at someone else’s expense. Instead of asking what they can learn from Israel’s achievements, they question whether those achievements were legitimate.

And that brings us back to Esav and Yaakov.

Esav willingly sold something valuable because he couldn’t appreciate its future importance. Yaakov recognized its value and was prepared to make a sacrifice to obtain it.

Later, Esav regretted what he had done. But instead of accepting responsibility for his decision, he blamed Yaakov.

And that is the real lesson.

When we see someone else succeed, we can either learn from that success or become jealous of it. We can try to build something ourselves, or we can resent what others have built.

Yaakov understood the importance of the future. Esav was concerned with satisfying his immediate desires.

And ultimately, that difference in attitude helped determine the paths they would take.

Success should inspire us to achieve, not encourage us to resent those who have achieved.

Something to think about.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.