We do not have lectures on Simhat Torah because the Torah belongs to all Jews. If we were to have speeches, then there would be some who would disagree and others would feel left out. We are united on Simhat Torah.
Now for a quick devar Torah.
There is something very strange about Simchat Torah.
Usually, when somebody finishes a masechet of Gemara or some other major work of Torah learning, we make a siyum. And what happens at a siyum? The person who finished gets up and gives a devar Torah. He explains what he learned, what it means to him, and perhaps shares some deeper insight.
But on Simchat Torah we finish the most important book we have—the Torah itself.
And where is the big devar Torah?
You would think that this would be the time for the greatest devar Torah of the entire year. But instead, what do we do?
We dance.
Why?
There are several reasons. First of all, we never really finish learning Torah. The moment we finish Vezot HaBracha, we immediately begin Bereishit. There is no real ending. Torah learning is a circle. Every time we come back to the beginning, hopefully we see something we didn’t see the year before.
But I think there is something even more important going on.
When somebody gives a devar Torah, there are always going to be people who understand it better than others. There may be somebody listening who disagrees with it—and Jews disagreeing with one another is certainly nothing new!
But even more importantly, there may be a simple Jew standing there who doesn’t understand the devar Torah at all.
On Simchat Torah, we don’t want anybody left out.
Because the Torah does not belong only to the rabbi. It doesn’t belong only to the scholar. It doesn’t belong only to the yeshiva student, the Hasid, the Modern Orthodox Jew, or any particular group.
The Torah belongs to every Jew.
I remember being at the Kotel, (the Western Wall), for Simchat Torah about twenty years ago. There was a little group of us dancing together. There was a Hasid. There were a couple of people like me, Modern Orthodox. And there was another fellow covered with tattoos.
Nobody asked anybody else how much Gemara he knew.
We were all dancing with the Torah.
That is Simchat Torah.
There is another beautiful part of the history of Simchat Torah. During the years of the Soviet Union, Simchat Torah became an occasion when Jews gathered publicly and expressed their Jewish identity, despite a regime that had tried for decades to suppress Jewish religious life. Jews who might hardly have known anything about Judaism came together to celebrate simply because they knew: This Torah is ours.
And then we do something else remarkable. We take the Torah out and dance with it publicly.
Because Torah is not supposed to remain locked away as our private possession. We have an obligation to bring its values into the world—not merely by preaching to other people, but by the way we ourselves behave.
If we want Torah to teach morality, then people should be able to see morality in us.
Perhaps that is why the greatest celebration of Torah doesn’t require a great scholar to stand up and give a complicated devar Torah.
Instead, we take the Torah in our arms.
We dance with it.
The scholar dances. The simple Jew dances. The Hasid dances. The Modern Orthodox Jew dances. The Jew with the tattoos dances.
Nobody has to pass a test before joining the circle.
Because on Simchat Torah, perhaps the most important lesson of Torah is taught without words:
The Torah belongs to all of us.
Something to think about.
