Yitzhak wanted to bless Esav but he was blind. Rivka knew that Esav did not deserve the blessing so she had Yaakov dress up as Esav. Rivka knew the true nature of her sons. Yitzhak was blinded by his narrative.
A Quick Dvar Torah: The Danger of Willful Blindness
Parshat Toldot
At the end of this week’s parsha, Toldot, we have the famous incident of Yitzchak giving his blessings to Yaakov instead of Esav.
The Torah tells us that Yitzchak had grown old and that his eyesight had become dim. He could no longer see clearly.
But there’s an interesting question here: Was Yitzchak blind only physically, or was he also blind spiritually?
You see, one of the great problems we face in life is that sometimes the evidence is right in front of us, but we simply refuse to see it.
Esav was not exactly the ideal person to carry on the spiritual legacy of Avraham and Yitzchak. He was a hunter, and according to the Midrash, he engaged in all sorts of questionable activities. He associated with violent people, and he married local Hittite women who caused tremendous grief to both Yitzchak and Rivka.
Rivka recognized these problems. She loved Esav. After all, he was her son. But she also understood that he was not the person who should become the spiritual leader of the family and carry on the covenant of Avraham.
Yitzchak, on the other hand, apparently didn’t see these things. Or perhaps he didn’t want to see them.
He saw the good in Esav. He loved his son, and he wanted to believe the best about him. But in doing so, he overlooked the evidence that was right in front of him.
And this is something that happens all the time.
We all know people who have friends who aren’t exactly the finest individuals in the world. They may do things that are dishonest or morally questionable, but we overlook those things because they’re our friends. We enjoy their company. We have a good time with them.
We don’t want to see their faults.
The same thing happens in families. Parents sometimes refuse to recognize the shortcomings of their children. They love their children, as they should, but love can sometimes blind us to reality.
And unfortunately, this also happens on a national level, sometimes with catastrophic consequences.
Think about Europe in the 1930s.
Britain and France pursued a policy of appeasement toward Hitler. They convinced themselves that if they gave him what he wanted, he would eventually be satisfied and there would be peace.
But Hitler had already made his intentions clear in Mein Kampf. His ideology and ambitions were there for anyone willing to read them.
Yet many political leaders preferred to believe their own narrative rather than confront the evidence before them.
And we know what happened.
We saw something similar in Israel before October 7, 2023.
There were warning signs about Hamas’s intentions. Israeli surveillance soldiers reported suspicious activities and preparations along the Gaza border. Yet their warnings were not given the attention they deserved.
Why?
Because there was a prevailing belief among important elements of Israel’s security establishment that Hamas was interested primarily in governing Gaza and improving its economic situation, rather than launching a major war against Israel.
That assumption proved disastrously wrong.
The evidence was there, but it didn’t fit the accepted narrative.
And that’s what we call willful blindness.
We become so attached to what we want to believe that we refuse to recognize what is actually happening.
Now, coming back to Yitzchak, the Torah is teaching us something very important.
One of the remarkable things about the Torah is that it doesn’t sugarcoat our forefathers and foremothers. It doesn’t portray them as perfect human beings who never made mistakes.
Avraham made difficult decisions. Yaakov made mistakes. And Yitzchak, despite his greatness and righteousness, may have allowed his love for Esav to prevent him from recognizing his son’s true character.
Rivka saw what Yitzchak could not, and she acted to ensure that Yaakov would receive the blessing intended for the continuation of the covenant.
The lesson is not that we shouldn’t love our children, our friends, or our country. Of course we should.
But love must never become an excuse for ignoring reality.
We have to be willing to look at the evidence, even when it makes us uncomfortable, even when it challenges our assumptions, and even when it tells us something we don’t want to hear.
Because sometimes the most dangerous kind of blindness isn’t the inability to see.
It’s the refusal to see what is right in front of our eyes.
And that’s something we should all think about.
Shabbat Shalom.
