According to the Ari (Rabbi Yitzhak Luria) Rachel is not buried in Rachel’s Tomb. But because so many people have prayed there over the centuries her spirit hovers over it. It is a case when holiness is created by people.
The Death and Burial of Rachel Imeinu
In this week’s parashah, we encounter the moving account of the death of Rachel Imeinu. Unlike the other Avot and Imahot, Rachel is not buried in the Me‘arat HaMachpelah in Hevron, but rather on the road near Beit Lechem, at what we know today as Kever Rachel. This raises several profound questions.
First, why was Rachel not buried together with the Patriarchs and Matriarchs?
One explanation offered by the commentators is deeply sensitive to human emotion. Yaakov understood the lifelong pain that Leah endured—feeling unloved and living in the shadow of her sister. Although Yaakov loved Leah, his love for Rachel was different and more visible. Yaakov therefore chose to be buried beside Leah, not Rachel, as a way of healing Leah’s pain for eternity and affirming her dignity.
A second question arises: is Rachel actually buried at Kever Rachel at all?
There is a tradition—cited by some authorities—that Rachel may not physically be buried there. When asked why this was not publicly emphasized, the response was striking: so many Jews have prayed there with sincerity that it is as though she truly is there.
This idea is illustrated by a modern parallel. After 1967, Israeli archaeologists conducted extensive studies on what is traditionally called King David’s Tomb. Using every available scientific method, they concluded that no one is buried there. When one of the researchers told his father—who prayed there daily—the father replied, “Your studies are wrong.” When pressed, he explained: How could it be that generations of Jews poured out their hearts there if David were not present in some way?
This teaches a powerful concept:
There are two kinds of holiness:
- Holiness from above, such as Mount Sinai, where God descended to humanity
- Holiness from below, created when human devotion sanctifies a place
Even if a site lacks physical remains, human prayer can invest it with real kedushah. Thus, when one prays at Kever Rachel, Rachel is truly present—in spirit, in memory, and in influence.
Finally, there is a profound national reason for Rachel’s burial location. Rachel is buried along the route taken by the Jewish people during the Babylonian exile. The prophet Yirmiyahu describes Rachel weeping for her children as they pass her grave. According to the Midrash, when God was angered by Israel’s sins, Rachel interceded:
“I allowed my sister to marry my husband and did not protest. If I could overcome my jealousy, surely You can overcome Your anger.”
Moved by her selflessness, God was appeased and promised that her children would return to their land.
Rachel, therefore, is not only a mother who died young—she is the eternal mother of hope, standing on the road of exile and whispering consolation and return.
There is much to reflect on in the death of Rachel Imeinu—about love, sacrifice, holiness, and redemption.
Leave a Reply