We learn that we have to be careful in what we say. There are those who will take our words and use them to justify evil acts. One who speaks like that is as guilty as the one who pulled the trigger.
Quick Devar Torah – Metzora, Lashon Hara, and the Power of Words
A couple of weeks ago, in Parshat Metzora, the Torah deals with lashon hara—harmful speech. What makes lashon hara so dangerous is that it doesn’t have to be false. In fact, it’s often true—or at least believed to be true by the person saying it.
That’s what makes it so destructive.
A lie is when I knowingly say something false. But lashon hara is when I repeat something damaging—even if I think it’s accurate—without considering the consequences. And once words are out there, they take on a life of their own. People interpret them, amplify them, and sometimes act on them in ways the speaker never intended.
The Torah is warning us: words are not neutral—they create reality.
We see this idea reflected throughout Chazal. In Pirkei Avot, we’re taught that arguments should be “for the sake of Heaven,” like those between Hillel and Shammai. They debated passionately—but with respect, friendship, and a shared goal of truth.
Contrast that with Korach and his followers. The Mishnah doesn’t describe it as a disagreement between Korach and Moshe—it calls it a dispute “of Korach and his assembly.” Because it wasn’t about truth. It was about ego, power, and self-interest. And that kind of conflict inevitably destroys itself.
That’s the dividing line:
- Healthy disagreement seeks truth.
- Destructive speech seeks to tear down.
We’re also in the period of the Omer, when we mourn the students of Rabbi Akiva. The Gemara tells us they died because they did not show proper respect for one another. These were great scholars—but even great people can fail in how they speak to and about each other.
That’s the message for us.
We can disagree—strongly. Anyone who’s learned in a chavruta knows that debate can be intense. But at the same time, we must always remember:
the person on the other side is not the enemy.
Words matter. Tone matters. Framing matters.
If our speech builds understanding, it’s like Hillel and Shammai.
If it fuels division and disrespect, it risks becoming something else entirely.
You see how relevant this is in today’s world. Take how President Trump is often spoken about in parts of the political sphere.
You hear very extreme language—labels, comparisons, and characterizations that go far beyond simple disagreement. Now, people absolutely have the right to disagree—even strongly. That’s part of a healthy society.
But the Torah is reminding us:
when disagreement turns into dehumanization, we’ve crossed a line.
Because once people stop seeing someone as a human being and start seeing them as something evil or beyond the pale, it changes how others hear it—and potentially how they act on it.
That’s not the way of Hillel and Shammai.
That starts to look more like Korach—where the goal is no longer truth, but tearing down.
One-line punch closing
“The Torah doesn’t ask us to agree—it asks us to speak in a way that disagreement doesn’t turn into destruction.”
And that’s exactly what the Torah is warning us about.
Leave a Reply